Prime HeadlineBeritalogyJurna CoreTasty Plate PediaBeauty Glow Pediakilas sepak bolaindokulinerbeautyniquejawara beritawellnesiahubastralythickuliner viralatletic zone hubzoonestifysorotan hari iniSudut LapanganCombatpediaTinta BeritaKuliner HariankuLuxurious BakingLacak Jejak SejarahBerita KecelakaanInformasi Harga SahamUpdate Seputar Berita PenipuanInformasi Seputar Harga EmasBerita Kecelakaan TerkiniBerita PenipuanInformasi Tentang Emasharga emas realtimeHarga Semen IndonesiaInformasi Kenaikan Harga EmasHarga SemenBerita Seputar EsportBerita Seputar KacaFashion IndonesiaBerita Harian SejatiUpdate Berita TerpercayaBerita Utama TerupdateSeklas Kabar BeritaInformasi Berita Bola TerkiniInformasi Berita CepatBerita Terbaru TerpopulerBerita Harian CepatSeputar Berita BolaPacu BeritaUpdate TeknoRanah AutoRumpi TetanggaMega Otomotifdunia faunaJelajah FaunaTatoo Art IndonesiaLoves Diet SehatSkena Fashionprediksi master hari iniUnited GamingFundacion RapalaFakta SehariTren HarapanGadgetkanGosipliciousiNewsComplexiNewsFootballPollux TierFoomer OfficialCommon SightJurnal TempoRuang MistisiNews CombatOhana MagazineLove Food Ready MealsPetite PaulinaBeauty RivalSpecialty Network SllcFilm Terbaru Penuh Pesan MoralMovie AutoAlmansorsMayumioteroCipta WacanaAkademi Keperawatan Yayasan UKIJurnal Keperawatan YUKISekolah Tinggi Ilmu Ekonomi Indonesia Surabayasensa138sensa138sensa138sensa138sensa138sensa138sensa138sensa138sensa138sensa138sensa138sensa138Round Rock JournalBiobaeckereiBornheimerBukemersanacokyakisirTrans To Findslot gacoraloha4daloha4daloha4dkiyo4dtgl.comkiyo4dbmx4dbmx4d loginbmx4d linkBrivifyjuliet4d loginjuliet4djuliet4d linkjuliet4d loginbima88bima88BIMAHOKIbimahokibimahokibima88bociljpsensa69bendera138bendera138bendera138bendera138bendera138bendera138algoritma rng keacakan digitalanimasi struktur reel interaktifbias konfirmasi hasil acakbudaya tradisional antarmuka digitalefek hampir berhasil persepsievolusi desain simbol visualmekanisme simbol pengganti gulunganornamen klasik desain kontemporersusunan payline kombinasi simbolwarna kontras persepsi keberuntunganotomatisasi interaksi dan ritme penggunapeluang teoretis dan kenyataan sampelsimbol oriental dan gerak visualsimbol pengganti dan pengganda interaktifsusunan simbol dalam variasi probabilitastradisi ubin dan industri digitalwaktu harian dan peluang matematisanggaran hiburan dan keputusan emosionalkebersamaan keluarga melalui tradisi ubinkeseimbangan budaya dalam desain digitalanimasi responsif perhatian penggunaefek scatter ekspektasi pemainevolusi mekanisme gulungan dinamis identitas budaya grafis kontemporerornamen mahjong hiburan digitalpeluang matematis pola semu rngpergantian simbol persepsi polaritme gulungan persepsi kecepatanstruktur visual pengalaman interaktifteknologi pengacakan kombinasi simbolalgoritma rng angka sulit diprediksiilusi kontrol prediksi putaran acakkeamanan qris verifikasi identitas digitalkomposisi warna persepsi antarmukamitologi fenghuang ilustrasi kekaisaranrendering kilauan simbol realistisrtp teoretis hasil aktual probabilitasshio macan desain karakter virtualsimbol scorpio karakter fantasi digitaltransformasi estetika klasik animasi interaktifanimasi berulang ekspektasi emosionalchipset stabilitas hp gamingevolusi dompet elektronik mobileidentitas ornamen visual modernilusi kendali pola acakprobabilitas digital prediksi pribadiresponsivitas mesin grafis interaktifstruktur payline evaluasi simboltempo animasi persepsi interaktiftransformasi ubin ikon virtualanimasi simbol interaktif dinamisantarmuka adaptif game moderndesain mahjong perangkat pintarefek suara konsentrasi smartphoneevolusi grafis hiburan digitalmekanisme simbol berantai gulunganpergantian reel pengalaman visualpsikologi warna tampilan cerahrng algoritma hasil acakwarisan mahjong menuju layaraudio animasi emosideposit digital smartphoneestetika oriental modernilusi kendali keacakanmahjong aksesibilitas selulerprobabilitas teori praktikprosesor respons animasiqris ekosistem gamerendering detail budayasimbol filosofi asiaspesifikasi sharp aquos sense11nikita mirzani live tiktok lollyproduk china pasar indonesiacolor walk redakan stresaplikasi direct instagram diujiriccardo calafiori di arsenaltransfer nicolo tresoldi milanlayanan purnajual united e motorreo runabout t4x truckpuffin atlantik burung lauttato simbol om hindunike air force gta 6kisah abu sufyan bin harbfilm jumanji open worldpochettino at manchester unitedanimasi berlapis pengalaman visual imersifantarmuka responsif interaksi permainanbias konfirmasi simbol berulangefek suara tradisional futuristikevolusi estetika oriental grafis modernfilosofi naga emas budaya asiaornamen giok identitas artistikqris keamanan transaksi platform gameshio kelinci karakter fantasi digitalvolatilitas tinggi distribusi hasil acakanimasi fokus perhatian layarevolusi antarmuka interaktifintegrasi dompet elektronikmahjong digital perangkat pintarmotif ubin tradisionalornamen klasik animasi modernpsikologi warna respons emosionalqris metode transaksi digitalrng hasil putaran acakspesifikasi hp tampilan demam gta 6 guncang industri gamingdunia virtual dan aksi seru gamingeksplorasi dunia terbuka gta 6fenomena komunitas gamer di era digitalgta 6 dunia virtual realistis orientalpergeseran tren gaming global onlineperkembangan teknologi ai dalam game modernpersaingan inovasi game modern menarikteknologi grafis gta 6 dan evolusiantusiasme peluncuran gta 6 baruemas dunia ketegangan global aset amanharga perak menguji batas optimismeharga emas peluang pembeli terbarusmartphone nubia terjangkau untuk pelajartragedi kilang cepu kementerian esdmpochettino manchester united era baruubed hong kong open chou tien chenzodiak virgo perubahan kecil kejutantranexamic acid serum noda hitamlaba laba penyelam rumah udarajapanese hojicha caramel roll cakedubai chocolate strawberry cupstren gourmet rice ball premiumdiet keto tempe alpukat menu lokalmisteri jembatan tua sosok putihxpeng g9l ultra awdsharp aquos sense11 terbaruford everest andalan penjualan indonesiamanfaat teh kesehatan pembuluh darahluis suarez messi pensiun inter miaminadira shafa minta maafconor mcgregor puji josh hokitnetanyahu terancam lengser ketua parlemenieu cepa ekspor indonesia eropakim ju ae ski mewahadaptasi mahjong dalam hiburan digitalanimasi kemenangan respons emosionalestetika tradisional sistem interaktifevolusi ornamen karakter visualingatan selektif kombinasi simbolprobabilitas distribusi hasil reelsimbol klasik hiburan kontemporertempo visual psikologi persepsitransisi halus desain gulunganvarians hasil permainan acakwaspada lowongan kerja palsuleo daniel perempat final hong kongharga timah ekspansi ai 2026serangan kartel narkoba hondurasajudan putin koper nuklir apecpotensi migas sulawesi baratukraina serang jembatan crimea rusiamerica ladaku residu pestisidacolorgram fruity glass tintwall pilates ruang terbatasperjalanan hercules mitologi yunanichris eubank jr kell brookrekomendasi makanan vietnam unikmango sticky rice bunshahi tukda saffron milkkiwi lime popsicles summerbotanical resin lamp floral artavoiding conflict false assumptionssouth korean student ai allegationsbrainy heels fashion trendantisipasi hadiah tidak pastiapofenia persepsi simbol acakevolusi animasi teknologi grafiskomposisi warna identitas visuallegenda keberuntungan karakter fantasiornamen tiongkok desain kontemporerseni tradisional ilustrasi komputersimbol kerbau filosofi ketekunantransisi animasi kenyamanan mataubin klasik antarmuka mobileanimasi simbol petunjuk visualantarmuka akses informasibias kognitif pengalaman terbarudinamika tempo durasi sesimultiplier perubahan nilaipola keluaran acakprobabilitas peluang kejadianrtp ekspektasi jangka panjangtransformasi ikon alurvolatilitas rentang hasil messi hadiah kenan yildizirish bella melahirkan caesar 2027amanda nunes kayla harrison rematchputusan genosida rohingya myanmartrik nail contouring kuku pendekbelanja impulsif media sosialgoogle gemini 4 neongta vi console performancetokyo smart bins akihabaramalaysia haze compensation demandcloud whatsapp backup chatdiva azzura tudingan tiru juleputin puji ekonomi indonesiabgn perketat pengawasan dapur mbgkenaikan ump jatim 2027nico paz nomor 10 argentinarumor transfer michael oliseyamaha rw155 di indonesiaisuzu d max reviewchimaera si hiu hantumakna tato perahu layarkoleksi kith star wars sithkisah hijrah shuhaib ar rumithe angry birds movie 3

Supreme Court backs residents against Tate Modern in viewing gallery case

The owners of flats adjacent to the Tate Gallery’s viewing platform have won their “privacy” case against the gallery. In fact, the case was brought under the law of nuisance rather than in privacy.

By a majority of 3-2 and in a Judgment given by Lord Leggatt, the Supreme Court has comprehensively re-stated the law of nuisance and explained where the two lower Courts (which decided in favour of the Tate) went wrong.

Regrettably, the Supreme Court declined to examine the question of whether the Court should grant an injunction against the Tate or award the flat owners damages instead.

Decision

The reasoning of the majority can be summarised as follows:

  • Nuisance is the interference with rights in or the enjoyment of land;
  • Nuisance can be caused by anything – there is no conceptual limit as to what can constitute a nuisance;
  • The phrase “unreasonable interference” with the rights or enjoyment of others has no special or explanatory meaning and is just another way of saying that the interference is unlawful.

Rather:

  1. The interference must be “substantial”. The Courts will not entertain claims for minor annoyances. The test of what counts as “substantial” is objective, to be assessed by reference to the standards of the ordinary or average person in the same position or to put it another way by reference to “the plain and sober and simple notions among the English people”. This is because the law of nuisance protects the utility of the land, and not the sensitivities of the people occupying it.
  2. The law affords greater protection to “ordinary uses” of land over “uncommon” or “extraordinary” uses. There are two aspects to this principle. First, “the common and ordinary use and occupation of land and houses may be done, if conveniently done” and such ordinary use will not constitute a nuisance. For example, building works, if done with due care and precautions, are not a nuisance. Second, one cannot increase the burden on their neighbours by putting their property to an extraordinary use.

Note that:

  • There is no separate concept of “reasonable user”. It is not a defence to a claim in nuisance to say that the Defendant is using their land reasonably in all the circumstances, as has been suggested in some earlier cases.
  • What amounts to the “ordinary use” of land is to be determined by reference to its locality. For example, noise or smells emanating from buildings in an industrial area may not be a nuisance in that area but may be in a residential area.
  • It is not a defence to say that the nuisance is in public interest or that the nuisance was ongoing before the Claimant arrived.

The majority held that it was straightforward to apply those principles to this case. The viewing platform means that hundreds of thousands of people per year can, and do, peer in to and take photographs of the flats. The original Judge compared living in the the flats to being on display in a zoo. There can be no doubt that this interferes with the ordinary use and enjoyment of the flats. Further “inviting members of the public to look out from a viewing gallery is manifestly a very particular and exceptional use of land. It cannot even be said to be a necessary or ordinary incident of operating an art museum.” It did not matter for this purpose whether the museum or the flats had come first (though it was the flats) or that the viewing gallery was in the public interest as a major attraction.

The original decision

The Supreme Court found that the original trial Judge had misapplied the law in three main ways:

  1. The Judge had asked whether the viewing gallery was a “reasonable use” of the Tate’s land in all the circumstances, rather than whether it was an “ordinary use”.
  2. The Judge had concluded that the flats (with floor to ceiling glass windows) were sensitive to this kind of visual intrusion and as a result, the gallery did not amount to a nuisance. However, this failed to draw a distinction between the ordinary and exceptional use of land. If the neighbouring property had been other flats or offices and people were looking out of those windows in the normal way then that would not have been a nuisance. Lord Leggatt stated: “The design of the building may in that way result in an occupier having to put up with greater interference with the ordinary use and enjoyment of her property than she would otherwise have to put up with – but only to the extent required to enable her neighbour to use his own property for the ordinary purposes of life.” However, this case was different because “the nature and extent of the viewing of the claimants’ flats goes far beyond anything that could reasonably be regarded as a necessary or natural consequence of the common and ordinary use and occupation of the Tate’s land”.
  3. The Judge had suggested that the owners could take steps to protect themselves, by lowering blinds or net curtains. The Supreme Court dismissed this notion, re-stating the principle that an owner should not have to alter the use of their property to abate a nuisance caused by another.

The Court of Appeal

The Court of Appeal had based its decision on the basis that “mere overlooking” could not constitute a nuisance. The Supreme Court held that there were various kinds of overlooking. “Overlooking” could mean the spatial relationship between one higher position and another lower one. That cannot constitute a nuisance. Similarly, the mere act of a neighbour looking at what is happening next door in the ordinary use of their own property may be an annoyance but cannot be a nuisance.

However, the Tate was inviting thousands of people to come and look from the gallery all day, every day of the week. Lord Leggatt said that this reasoning was “like arguing that, because ordinary household noise caused by neighbours does not constitute a nuisance, inviting a brass band to practise all day every day in my back garden cannot be an actionable nuisance”.

Public Interest

Finally, the Supreme Court suggested that the decisions of the lower Courts had been driven by policy reasons, and in particular the question of how public interest should be balanced against private property rights. The Supreme Court held that public interest can never be relevant to the question of liability, noting:

“The point of the law of private nuisance is to protect equality of rights between neighbouring occupiers to the use and enjoyment of their own land when those rights conflict. In deciding whether one party’s use has infringed the other’s rights, the public utility of the conflicting uses is not relevant.”

However, the Court noted that property rights are not absolute and can be subordinated to the public interest, for example in a major infrastructure project:

“But it is fundamental to the integrity of any system of property rights that, in any such case, the individuals whose rights are infringed or overridden receive compensation for the violation of their rights. In other words, the public interest may sometimes justify awarding damages rather than granting an injunction to restrain the defendant’s harmful activity, but it cannot justify denying the victim any remedy at all.”

Remedy

The Courts have a discretion as whether to grant an injunction, or award damages instead. Historically, the Courts would refuse an injunction if the injury was considered small, damages would be an adequate remedy and it would be oppressive to grant an injunction. The Supreme Court examined this issue in Coventry v Lawrence (another case involving nuisance). The Court there held that the decision was an exercise of discretion that should not be fettered but “because of the divergent opinions of the Justices” there is little guidance as to how that discretion should be exercised.

This would have been an opportunity for the Supreme Court to provide such guidance, but it declined to do so and remitted the issue back to the High Court for determination. The suggestion appears to be that the Tate should put forward some proposals to mitigate the viewing, for example by installing louvres and, given such an indication, this issue may well settle before it comes back to Court.

Impact

The case is likely to generate significant interest in the short term – particularly as the media headlines suggest that it is a “privacy” case. This is not right. Rather, the Supreme Court is clear that ordinary instances of overlooking between neighbours are not actionable and nor is ordinary development. The crucial element is whether the land in question is being put to an ordinary or extraordinary use.

In the longer term, it is the question of “ordinary use” which is likely to generate further litigation. It is difficult to assess ordinary use by reference to locality in highly developed mixed areas, or where uses are developed incrementally over time and the Court provides little guidance on this issue.

Further, the issue of how the Courts should approach remedies in cases such as this will continue to plague the Courts and litigants alike. This is a missed opportunity for the Court to provide some guidance in this area. It will be interesting to see what the High Court decides on this issue, if the parties are unable to reach an agreement in the meantime.

Thomas Freeman is a Senior Associate Solicitor at Irwin Mitchell.

Want to have your say? Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Read more stories

Join over 7,000 conveyancing professionals – Check back daily for all the latest news, views, insights and best practice and sign up to our e-newsletter to receive our daily and weekly round ups

You’ll receive the latest updates, analysis, and best practice straight to your inbox.

Features

Generic selectors
Exact matches only
Search in title
Search in content
Post Type Selectors
Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies so that we can provide you with the best user experience possible. Cookie information is stored in your browser and performs functions such as recognising you when you return to our website and helping our team to understand which sections of the website you find most interesting and useful.