Prime HeadlineBeritalogyJurna CoreTasty Plate PediaBeauty Glow Pediakilas sepak bolaindokulinerbeautyniquejawara beritawellnesiahubastralythickuliner viralatletic zone hubzoonestifysorotan hari iniSudut LapanganCombatpediaTinta BeritaKuliner HariankuLuxurious BakingLacak Jejak SejarahBerita KecelakaanInformasi Harga SahamUpdate Seputar Berita PenipuanInformasi Seputar Harga EmasBerita Kecelakaan TerkiniBerita PenipuanInformasi Tentang Emasharga emas realtimeHarga Semen IndonesiaInformasi Kenaikan Harga EmasHarga SemenBerita Seputar EsportBerita Seputar KacaFashion IndonesiaBerita Harian SejatiUpdate Berita TerpercayaBerita Utama TerupdateSeklas Kabar BeritaInformasi Berita Bola TerkiniInformasi Berita CepatBerita Terbaru TerpopulerBerita Harian CepatSeputar Berita BolaPacu BeritaUpdate TeknoRanah AutoRumpi TetanggaMega Otomotifdunia faunaJelajah FaunaTatoo Art IndonesiaLoves Diet SehatSkena Fashionprediksi master hari iniUnited GamingFundacion RapalaFakta SehariTren HarapanGadgetkanGosipliciousiNewsComplexiNewsFootballPollux TierFoomer OfficialCommon SightJurnal TempoRuang MistisiNews CombatOhana MagazineLove Food Ready MealsPetite PaulinaBeauty RivalSpecialty Network SllcFilm Terbaru Penuh Pesan MoralMovie AutoAlmansorsMayumioteroCipta WacanaAkademi Keperawatan Yayasan UKIJurnal Keperawatan YUKISekolah Tinggi Ilmu Ekonomi Indonesia Surabayasensa138sensa138sensa138sensa138sensa138sensa138sensa138sensa138sensa138sensa138sensa138sensa138Round Rock JournalBiobaeckereiBornheimerBukemersanacokyakisirTrans To Findslot gacoraloha4daloha4daloha4dkiyo4dtgl.comkiyo4dbmx4dbmx4d loginbmx4d linkBrivifyjuliet4d loginjuliet4djuliet4d linkjuliet4d loginbima88bima88BIMAHOKIbimahokibimahokibima88bociljpsensa69bendera138bendera138bendera138bendera138bendera138bendera138algoritma rng keacakan digitalanimasi struktur reel interaktifbias konfirmasi hasil acakbudaya tradisional antarmuka digitalefek hampir berhasil persepsievolusi desain simbol visualmekanisme simbol pengganti gulunganornamen klasik desain kontemporersusunan payline kombinasi simbolwarna kontras persepsi keberuntunganotomatisasi interaksi dan ritme penggunapeluang teoretis dan kenyataan sampelsimbol oriental dan gerak visualsimbol pengganti dan pengganda interaktifsusunan simbol dalam variasi probabilitastradisi ubin dan industri digitalwaktu harian dan peluang matematisanggaran hiburan dan keputusan emosionalkebersamaan keluarga melalui tradisi ubinkeseimbangan budaya dalam desain digitalanimasi responsif perhatian penggunaefek scatter ekspektasi pemainevolusi mekanisme gulungan dinamis identitas budaya grafis kontemporerornamen mahjong hiburan digitalpeluang matematis pola semu rngpergantian simbol persepsi polaritme gulungan persepsi kecepatanstruktur visual pengalaman interaktifteknologi pengacakan kombinasi simbolalgoritma rng angka sulit diprediksiilusi kontrol prediksi putaran acakkeamanan qris verifikasi identitas digitalkomposisi warna persepsi antarmukamitologi fenghuang ilustrasi kekaisaranrendering kilauan simbol realistisrtp teoretis hasil aktual probabilitasshio macan desain karakter virtualsimbol scorpio karakter fantasi digitaltransformasi estetika klasik animasi interaktifanimasi berulang ekspektasi emosionalchipset stabilitas hp gamingevolusi dompet elektronik mobileidentitas ornamen visual modernilusi kendali pola acakprobabilitas digital prediksi pribadiresponsivitas mesin grafis interaktifstruktur payline evaluasi simboltempo animasi persepsi interaktiftransformasi ubin ikon virtualanimasi simbol interaktif dinamisantarmuka adaptif game moderndesain mahjong perangkat pintarefek suara konsentrasi smartphoneevolusi grafis hiburan digitalmekanisme simbol berantai gulunganpergantian reel pengalaman visualpsikologi warna tampilan cerahrng algoritma hasil acakwarisan mahjong menuju layaraudio animasi emosideposit digital smartphoneestetika oriental modernilusi kendali keacakanmahjong aksesibilitas selulerprobabilitas teori praktikprosesor respons animasiqris ekosistem gamerendering detail budayasimbol filosofi asiaspesifikasi sharp aquos sense11nikita mirzani live tiktok lollyproduk china pasar indonesiacolor walk redakan stresaplikasi direct instagram diujiriccardo calafiori di arsenaltransfer nicolo tresoldi milanlayanan purnajual united e motorreo runabout t4x truckpuffin atlantik burung lauttato simbol om hindunike air force gta 6kisah abu sufyan bin harbfilm jumanji open worldpochettino at manchester unitedanimasi berlapis pengalaman visual imersifantarmuka responsif interaksi permainanbias konfirmasi simbol berulangefek suara tradisional futuristikevolusi estetika oriental grafis modernfilosofi naga emas budaya asiaornamen giok identitas artistikqris keamanan transaksi platform gameshio kelinci karakter fantasi digitalvolatilitas tinggi distribusi hasil acakanimasi fokus perhatian layarevolusi antarmuka interaktifintegrasi dompet elektronikmahjong digital perangkat pintarmotif ubin tradisionalornamen klasik animasi modernpsikologi warna respons emosionalqris metode transaksi digitalrng hasil putaran acakspesifikasi hp tampilan demam gta 6 guncang industri gamingdunia virtual dan aksi seru gamingeksplorasi dunia terbuka gta 6fenomena komunitas gamer di era digitalgta 6 dunia virtual realistis orientalpergeseran tren gaming global onlineperkembangan teknologi ai dalam game modernpersaingan inovasi game modern menarikteknologi grafis gta 6 dan evolusiantusiasme peluncuran gta 6 baruemas dunia ketegangan global aset amanharga perak menguji batas optimismeharga emas peluang pembeli terbarusmartphone nubia terjangkau untuk pelajartragedi kilang cepu kementerian esdmpochettino manchester united era baruubed hong kong open chou tien chenzodiak virgo perubahan kecil kejutantranexamic acid serum noda hitamlaba laba penyelam rumah udarajapanese hojicha caramel roll cakedubai chocolate strawberry cupstren gourmet rice ball premiumdiet keto tempe alpukat menu lokalmisteri jembatan tua sosok putihxpeng g9l ultra awdsharp aquos sense11 terbaruford everest andalan penjualan indonesiamanfaat teh kesehatan pembuluh darahluis suarez messi pensiun inter miaminadira shafa minta maafconor mcgregor puji josh hokitnetanyahu terancam lengser ketua parlemenieu cepa ekspor indonesia eropakim ju ae ski mewahadaptasi mahjong dalam hiburan digitalanimasi kemenangan respons emosionalestetika tradisional sistem interaktifevolusi ornamen karakter visualingatan selektif kombinasi simbolprobabilitas distribusi hasil reelsimbol klasik hiburan kontemporertempo visual psikologi persepsitransisi halus desain gulunganvarians hasil permainan acakwaspada lowongan kerja palsuleo daniel perempat final hong kongharga timah ekspansi ai 2026serangan kartel narkoba hondurasajudan putin koper nuklir apecpotensi migas sulawesi baratukraina serang jembatan crimea rusiamerica ladaku residu pestisidacolorgram fruity glass tintwall pilates ruang terbatasperjalanan hercules mitologi yunanichris eubank jr kell brookrekomendasi makanan vietnam unikmango sticky rice bunshahi tukda saffron milkkiwi lime popsicles summerbotanical resin lamp floral artavoiding conflict false assumptionssouth korean student ai allegationsbrainy heels fashion trendantisipasi hadiah tidak pastiapofenia persepsi simbol acakevolusi animasi teknologi grafiskomposisi warna identitas visuallegenda keberuntungan karakter fantasiornamen tiongkok desain kontemporerseni tradisional ilustrasi komputersimbol kerbau filosofi ketekunantransisi animasi kenyamanan mataubin klasik antarmuka mobileanimasi simbol petunjuk visualantarmuka akses informasibias kognitif pengalaman terbarudinamika tempo durasi sesimultiplier perubahan nilaipola keluaran acakprobabilitas peluang kejadianrtp ekspektasi jangka panjangtransformasi ikon alurvolatilitas rentang hasil messi hadiah kenan yildizirish bella melahirkan caesar 2027amanda nunes kayla harrison rematchputusan genosida rohingya myanmartrik nail contouring kuku pendekbelanja impulsif media sosialgoogle gemini 4 neongta vi console performancetokyo smart bins akihabaramalaysia haze compensation demandcloud whatsapp backup chatdiva azzura tudingan tiru juleputin puji ekonomi indonesiabgn perketat pengawasan dapur mbgkenaikan ump jatim 2027nico paz nomor 10 argentinarumor transfer michael oliseyamaha rw155 di indonesiaisuzu d max reviewchimaera si hiu hantumakna tato perahu layarkoleksi kith star wars sithkisah hijrah shuhaib ar rumithe angry birds movie 3tradisi feng shui keseimbangan energifilosofi elemen logam dan air orientalfilosofi tata ruang feng shuiinovasi teknologi smartphone masa kinijejak kebudayaan feng shui kemakmuranpanduan aplikasi analisis smartphoneperforma smartphone ai untuk kebiasaan terukurperkembangan smartphone ai ubah cara pemainteknologi smartphone pendukung analisis cerdaswarna pembawa keberuntungan menurut feng shuichipset generasi terbaru smartphone gaming responsifkombinasi chipset dan sistem pendingin smartphonekombinasi performa perangkat untuk gamingmemaksimalkan koneksi 5g dan stabilitas jaringanmengoptimalkan performa smartphone dengan prosesorperforma prosesor mobile untuk gamingperkembangan smartphone gaming berbasis airefresh rate tinggi di smartphone flagshipteknologi ai gpu smartphone modernteknologi touch sampling rate layar responsif smartphonegta 6 resmi rilisperekrutan tentara bayaran rusiavasektomi tanggung jawab priamaruf amin mundur wantim muinico paz pewaris nomor messitoyota land cruiser fj indonesiaparadoks ruu perampasan asetvaio s13 pro pg esimmengenal active recovery tubuhkeringat berlebihan tidak kepanasansotong ahli kamuflase mengubah warnathe hunger games kelima puluhavocado chocolate trufflesmugwort cream rice cakejollibee honey garlic chickenseven coloured earth mauritiusdopamine decor modernhouses make strange noisesjennifer lawrence new breast implantsbest affordable foundations mature skinmahjong ways estetika orientaltren mahjong generasi zshio naga mahjong digitalzodiak scorpio desain mahjongmahjong ways animasi mobileshio kuda inspirasi gamezodiak leo mahjong visualpsikologi pola mahjong waysshio kelinci mahjong estetikamasa depan mahjong digital aimahjong ways transformasi digitalmahjong digital anak mudazodiak mahjong budaya digitalshio naga budaya mahjongmahjong ways warisan budayalibra keseimbangan mahjongtren mahjong media sosialshio kuda filosofi mahjongmahjong ways era smartphonescorpio misteri simbol mahjongevolusi mahjong ways generasi mudamahjong digital budaya visual anak mudafilosofi shio naga mahjong digitalzodiak scorpio karakter mahjongbudaya hoki tradisi mahjong ways shio kuda karakter digitalpsikologi warna mahjong waysgenerasi z konten mahjong digitalanimasi transformasi mahjong digitalmitos zodiak shio probabilitasemas dunia merosot pasar gelisahharga perak dolar permintaan industriharga emas menjelang desemberpolusi udara influenza Kesehatan anakambisi indonesia geser dominasi thailandpersita klasemen super league bergejolakubed kalahkan toma junior popovshio tikus akhir 2026tren biohacking beauty kulitsiput laut costasiella mirip domba kecil tubuh hijaunya menggemaskanjapanese mentaiko butter rollfenomena kuliner nostalgia jadulresep bakwan jagung telur asintren diet paleo 2026motogp portugal 2026 fp1 resultsunusual apec summit momentsetf emas investor chinaoperasi siber rahasia inggrisburon narkoba singapura ditangkap thailanddesain interior modern nusantarapria muda gagal ginjal cuci darahsharp aquos sense11 meluncurpromo kawasaki imos 2026legenda gunung berkabut nama terlarangmahjong ways budaya teknologi generasi mudashio kelinci filosofi mahjong digitalshio macan transformasi mahjongshio naga mahjong ways budayatampilan mahjong ways hiburan digitalteknologi animasi mahjong waysteknologi visual mahjongtren permainan digital anak muda interaktifzodiak gemini mahjong simbol psikologizodiak leo simbol mahjong kontenzodiak libra mahjong estetika oriental

To rely or not to rely on a common-intention constructive trust?

To rely or not to rely on a common-intention constructive trust: an instance of the application of s. 53(1)(c) of the Law of Property Act 1925 | By John Clargo, Barrister, Gatehouse Chambers

On 14th December 2022, the Court of Appeal overturned March’s High Court decision that detrimental reliance is not a necessary element of a claim based on the doctrine of common-intention constructive trust (while also showing that there was no need to rely on the doctrine in the first place).

Hudson v. Hathway [2022] EWCA Civ 1648, [2022] EWHC 631 (QB)

The factual background

In 1990 Mr Hudson and Ms Hathway started a relationship. He moved into her house and it was put into joint names. They had two sons. They moved to another house, again in joint names. In 2007 they moved to a third house, Picnic House, which was purchased with the assistance of a mortgage, and again placed into joint names. Ms Hathway had given up working while caring for their children but had subsequently gone back to work in the charity sector. Mr Hudson had continued to work lucratively in the insurance industry. His contributions to the mortgage significantly outstripped hers over time.

In 2009 Mr Hudson left. The mortgage was converted into an interest-only mortgage and continued to be serviced out of a joint account into which both salaries were paid. In 2011 Picnic House suffered a significant oil-spill from neighbouring land which led to a protracted insurance claim and difficulties in selling it.

Mr Hudson and Ms Hathway corresponded by email about tidying up their financial affairs in the aftermath of their relationship. At the end of 2011 she emailed him to say that, in her view, certain shares owned by him, which he had asserted to be worthless, formed (like his pension fund) part of their “collective assets” in that their relationship together had allowed his personal career to advance. Mr Hudson replied to the effect that things which had accrued during their relationship was something that they should reach an agreement on.

In mid-2013 Mr Hudson asserted that he should retain what had accrued from his “personal graft” but that Ms Hathway could have “the liquid cash …savings in the bank … physical property, the contents of the house”. He went on to say: “Which leaves the house, a bad asset which is preventing all of us [from] … moving on with our lives …. You know what, I want none of the proceeds of that either. Take it. Buy yourself somewhere you can afford to live…. What I want is an end to it. So have everything that’s available now and when the house is sold.”

She asked him to confirm that he meant that he should get “sole ownership of your shares and pension” and she should have “the equity from the house, the house contents, savings and income from endowments”. She said if she had understood correctly, then she would do what she could to get the house sold as soon as the oil spill had been dealt with. He wrote: “Yes, that’s right. […] Under this arrangement, I’ve no interest whatsoever in the house, so whilst I will continue to contribute, I won’t do so forever.”

In early 2015 Mr Hudson ceased making contributions to the mortgage. Ms Hathway took over payments, that being cheaper than renting.

The proceedings

In October 2019, Mr Hudson issued a CPR 8 claim under the Trusts of Land and Appointment of Trustees Act 1996 claim seeking an order for sale and … an equal division of the net proceeds of sale. Ms Hathway argued that the agreement reached in mid-2013 that she should have the net proceeds of sale (which was not in dispute) was enforceable as a common-intention constructive trust, she having relied to her detriment in (1) making all interest payments since early 2015 and managing her lifestyle so as to be able to afford to, (2) making no claim in respect of Mr Hudson’s shares and pension, (3) making no claim for financial support for their sons, (4) dealing with the house and its various issues alone since 2014. The necessity for asserting a constructive trust arose because it was not in dispute that the “deal” reached in the email correspondence summarised above did not satisfy the requirements of either s. 2 of the Law of Property (Miscellaneous) Provisions 1989 or s. 53(1) of the Law of Property Act (“LPA”)1925.

The trial

The trial judge, His Honour Judge Ralton, found in favour of Ms Hathway. He considered that only the failure to make a claim in respect of Mr Hudson’s shares and pension amounted to relevant detriment, notwithstanding that their not being married meant that she in fact had no matrimonial claim: the learned judge thought that there might have been a (weak) constructive trust civil claim to the shares. Consequently, it was not necessary for Ms Hathway to succeed on the argument advanced by her counsel – which the trial judge rejected – that detrimental reliance was not in fact required to establish a common-intention constructive trust in a domestic consumer context.

The first appeal(s)

Mr Hudson appealed against the judge’s finding that there was detriment. Ms Hathway appealed against his decision that she could not win absent detrimental reliance and against his rejection of the non pension/shares issues as detriment.

Kerr J. held on the cross-appeal that detrimental reliance was no longer a necessary element in establishing a common-intention constructive trust. The introductory paragraph to that part of his judgment began: “Although 39 authorities were cited to me, I propose to cite only a few of them, in the hope that clarity will not be lost among the detail.” In summary, he accepted the submission that detrimental reliance was no longer a necessary element of a common-intention constructive trust because otherwise it would have been mentioned in the majority decisions in Stack v. Dowden and Jones v. Kernott. That meant Ms Hathway’s appeal succeeded regardless of Kerr J’s approach to HHJ Ralton’s approach to detriment (with which, he would have declined to interfere).

The second appeal(s)

Mr Hudson again appealed in relation to both the requirement for detriment and its existence. Lewison L.J. (with whom Andrews L.J. and Nugee L.J. agreed) held in a detailed judgment that while Kerr J. was right not to interfere with the decision as to whether detriment had been established in this case he was wrong on the issue of whether detriment was a necessary element of a common-intention constructive trust, regardless of the context. He cited 29 cases before, after, and including Stack v. Dowden and Jones v. Kernott, stretching from Gissing v. Gissing in 1971 to Guest v. Guest in 2022 as showing a long line of clear and consistent authority for such a proposition, supported by all the main text books.

However, while the Court of Appeal was at pains to make absolutely clear that detrimental reliance remains very much at the heart of the doctrine of the common-intention constructive trust, this was not, in fact, the reason why the appeal was unsuccessful. At the Court of Appeal’s prompting Ms Hathway took the point (not taken before HHJ Ralton or Kerr J.) that the email correspondence between the parties in 2013 (materially set out above) complied with the statutory formality required by s. 53(1)(c) LPA 1925 for the disposition of an equitable interest (in land), namely that it be “in writing signed by the person disposing of the same…”.

The Court of Appeal held that the emails from Mr Hudson were sufficient to amount to dispositions of his unsecured joint interest in Picnic House within the meaning of s. 36 LPA 1925 and that there was a substantial body of authority to support the proposition that, because he had concluded them“Lee” or “Lee Hudson” they also satisfied the requirement in s. 53(1)(c) LPA 1925 of being signed, notwithstanding that parliament would not have known what an email was in 1925. Lewison L.J. expressed the view that it was difficult to see why the point had not been taken before.

So, at the end of the day, Ms Hathway succeeded in establishing that her interest in Picnic House had increased from 50% to 100% in the light of her email communications in 2013. In doing so, she had succeeded on three occasions in establishing detriment while failing on two of them to establishing that such detriment was not in fact required: not exactly a walk in the park. However, given that neither of those points turned out to be necessary to decide the case, it seems that you don’t need a long walk in the park to benefit from a Picnic.

Want to have your say? Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Read more stories

Join over 7,000 conveyancing professionals – Check back daily for all the latest news, views, insights and best practice and sign up to our e-newsletter to receive our daily and weekly round ups

You’ll receive the latest updates, analysis, and best practice straight to your inbox.

Features

Generic selectors
Exact matches only
Search in title
Search in content
Post Type Selectors
Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies so that we can provide you with the best user experience possible. Cookie information is stored in your browser and performs functions such as recognising you when you return to our website and helping our team to understand which sections of the website you find most interesting and useful.