Prime HeadlineBeritalogyJurna CoreTasty Plate PediaBeauty Glow Pediakilas sepak bolaindokulinerbeautyniquejawara beritawellnesiahubastralythickuliner viralatletic zone hubzoonestifysorotan hari iniSudut LapanganCombatpediaTinta BeritaKuliner HariankuLuxurious BakingLacak Jejak SejarahBerita KecelakaanInformasi Harga SahamUpdate Seputar Berita PenipuanInformasi Seputar Harga EmasBerita Kecelakaan TerkiniBerita PenipuanInformasi Tentang Emasharga emas realtimeHarga Semen IndonesiaInformasi Kenaikan Harga EmasHarga SemenBerita Seputar EsportBerita Seputar KacaFashion IndonesiaBerita Harian SejatiUpdate Berita TerpercayaBerita Utama TerupdateSeklas Kabar BeritaInformasi Berita Bola TerkiniInformasi Berita CepatBerita Terbaru TerpopulerBerita Harian CepatSeputar Berita BolaPacu BeritaUpdate TeknoRanah AutoRumpi TetanggaMega Otomotifdunia faunaJelajah FaunaTatoo Art IndonesiaLoves Diet SehatSkena Fashionprediksi master hari iniUnited GamingFundacion RapalaFakta SehariTren HarapanGadgetkanGosipliciousiNewsComplexiNewsFootballPollux TierFoomer OfficialCommon SightJurnal TempoRuang MistisiNews CombatOhana MagazineLove Food Ready MealsPetite PaulinaBeauty RivalSpecialty Network SllcFilm Terbaru Penuh Pesan MoralMovie AutoAlmansorsMayumioteroCipta WacanaAkademi Keperawatan Yayasan UKIJurnal Keperawatan YUKISekolah Tinggi Ilmu Ekonomi Indonesia Surabayasensa138sensa138sensa138sensa138sensa138sensa138sensa138sensa138sensa138sensa138sensa138sensa138Round Rock JournalBiobaeckereiBornheimerBukemersanacokyakisirTrans To Findslot gacoraloha4daloha4daloha4dkiyo4dtgl.comkiyo4dbmx4dbmx4d loginbmx4d linkBrivifyjuliet4d loginjuliet4djuliet4d linkjuliet4d loginbima88bima88BIMAHOKIbimahokibimahokibima88bociljpsensa69bendera138bendera138bendera138bendera138bendera138bendera138mahjong ways estetika orientaltren mahjong generasi zshio naga mahjong digitalzodiak scorpio desain mahjongmahjong ways animasi mobileshio kuda inspirasi gamezodiak leo mahjong visualpsikologi pola mahjong waysshio kelinci mahjong estetikamasa depan mahjong digital aimahjong ways transformasi digitalmahjong digital anak mudazodiak mahjong budaya digitalshio naga budaya mahjongmahjong ways warisan budayalibra keseimbangan mahjongtren mahjong media sosialshio kuda filosofi mahjongmahjong ways era smartphonescorpio misteri simbol mahjongevolusi mahjong ways generasi mudamahjong digital budaya visual anak mudafilosofi shio naga mahjong digitalzodiak scorpio karakter mahjongbudaya hoki tradisi mahjong waysshio kuda karakter digitalpsikologi warna mahjong waysgenerasi z konten mahjong digitalanimasi transformasi mahjong digital mitos zodiak shio probabilitasemas dunia merosot pasar gelisahharga perak dolar permintaan industriharga emas menjelang desemberpolusi udara influenza Kesehatan anakambisi indonesia geser dominasi thailandpersita klasemen super league bergejolakubed kalahkan toma junior popovshio tikus akhir 2026tren biohacking beauty kulitsiput laut costasiella mirip domba kecil tubuh hijaunya menggemaskanjapanese mentaiko butter rollfenomena kuliner nostalgia jadulresep bakwan jagung telur asintren diet paleo 2026motogp portugal 2026 fp1 resultsunusual apec summit momentsetf emas investor chinaoperasi siber rahasia inggrisburon narkoba singapura ditangkap thailanddesain interior modern nusantarapria muda gagal ginjal cuci darahsharp aquos sense11 meluncurpromo kawasaki imos 2026legenda gunung berkabut nama terlarangmahjong ways budaya teknologi generasi mudashio kelinci filosofi mahjong digitalshio macan transformasi mahjongshio naga mahjong ways budayatampilan mahjong ways hiburan digitalteknologi animasi mahjong waysteknologi visual mahjongtren permainan digital anak muda interaktifzodiak gemini mahjong simbol psikologizodiak leo simbol mahjong kontenzodiak libra mahjong estetika orientalharga emas antam ubs koreksiharga perak prospek investasi globalharga emas zona panas investorputusan icj soal myanmar jadi sorotan rohingya menanti keadilanoppo find x10 smartphone premiumshin tae yong persija hadapi psmmarc marquez gelar MotoGP sejarahzodiak cancer keputusan cintatren architectural collar dresskelelawar hammer headed kepala besarpistachio raspberry mousse domenasi tumpang kediri menyimpan keunikan sambal tempe semangitkonsep Korean vinyl dessert bardiet ocd berat stagnanharga redmi 17 5gkerusakan rumah tasya farasyarisiko kanker kulit di indonesiapenyebab mudah mabuk perjalanankarang gigi radang gusirespons conte manchester unitedtransfer mudryk arsenal chelseaharga byd titan 7 dmvw polo gti clubsport conceptantelop saiga stepa eurasiamakna tato dandelion minimalisnoah converse chuck 70 tartankisah sahabat abu dujanahfilm violent night 2newcastle vs arsenal predictioncop31 memanas komitmen energidua kapal dilarang berlayarnamu balai kota ondel ondeljuara angkat besi malaysia kecelakaanhuawei osta hp flagshipupah minimum jawa tengahmyanmar tolak putusan icj rohingyatren rok satin panjangmakanan tinggi flavonoid sehatmitologi suku aceh alamamari jones tko deaundre pettuskuah pliek u khas acehvegetable cream cheese bagelcheese tteokbokki recipesasian gyeran ppang koreanus chip restrictions tsmcfinding happiness in simpletravis kelce falcons ankle tackleluminous holiday eye makeup trendsaplikasi ojek online tutupanimasi mahjong waysanak muda mahjong video pendekgenerasi z mahjong budaya populeraudio mahjong waysmahjong digital desain ponselmahjong digital audio visual perangkat mahjong ways perubahan desain antarmukamahjong ways estetika orientalmahjong ways transisi layarmahjong ways tipografi antarmukashio anjing mahjong loyalitasmahjong ways warna emas psikologishio babi mahjong ornamenshio ayam mahjong identitas karaktershio kerbau mahjongshio kambing mahjong estetikashio monyet mahjongshio kuda mahjong simbol dinamikashio ular mahjongshio tikus mahjong cerita kreatifzodiak aquarius mahjongtren mahjong komunitas mudazodiak cancer mahjong narasizodiak aries mahjong simbol energizodiak pisces mahjongzodiak capricorn mahjong teknologizodiak scorpio mahjong misteri visualzodiak sagitarius mahjongzodiak virgo mahjong detail visualzodiak taurus mahjong warnarummenigge bela petinggi bayern musialaerin wartia tersangka penganiayaan artufc qatar prochazka stirlinginggris operasi siber empat negaraasean ekonomi myanmar laut china selataneksekusi suntik mati texas kontroversilibernt windows 11 alternativeanime crusaders x codes november 2026virgil van dijk liverpool futurendonesian stock market declineevolusi mahjong ways digitalgen z tradisi mahjongleo karakter fantasi mahjonglibra harmoni mahjong digitalmahjong digital gen zsejarah mahjong hiburan digitalshio kelinci ilustrasi mahjongshio naga mahjong waystren konten mahjong sosialwarna emas hijau mahjongmahjong ways dan rahasia daya tarik simbol emas dalam budaya keberuntungan digitalketika shio naga bertemu mahjong digital: mitos hoki dan pesona visual yang tak pernah pudarzodiak libra dalam dunia mahjong modern: harmoni warna dan ilusi keseimbangan keberuntunganfilosofi shio ular dan mahjong ways: mengapa simbol misterius membuat pengalaman digital lebih memikatmisteri angka delapan pada mahjong digital: dari tradisi hoki hingga psikologi penggunamahjong ways dan zodiak pisces: imajinasi, warna biru, serta cerita keberuntungan di layarshio monyet dalam hiburan mahjong digital: kreativitas, kejutan, dan daya tarik animasi interaktifmengapa efek cahaya mahjong ways terasa membawa hoki? penjelasan desain dan psikologizodiak sagitarius dan mahjong digital: semangat petualangan dalam estetika permainan masa kiniantara hoki dan algoritma mahjong ways: mengapa pola berulang belum tentu menjadi petunjukanimasi mahjong ways mobileaquarius inovasi mahjongestetika oriental mahjongmusik efek suara mahjongpisces fantasi mahjongpsikologi probabilitas mahjongshio kuda visual mahjongshio macan karakter digitalshio ular desain mahjongsimbol mahjong desain kreatifstruktur 5 gulungan 4 baris menarikperhitungan matematika dalam pengelolaan modalangka favorit dan riwayat roulettebonus kasino menggiurkan syarat tersembunyimemahami hubungan return volatilitas risikomenguji strategi dengan data simulasimetode probabilitas perbandingan peluang kasinosatu keputusan meja baccarat pentingstrategi blackjack dan keputusan akhirteori expected value di kasino digitalemas dunia data ekonomi pekan baruharga perak menguji optimisme investorharga emas babak krusial pasarkenaikan ump 2027 berbagai provinsitubuh menggigil tanpa demampersija gagal kalahkan psmtiwi fadia world tour finalsshio anjing dan misteri rezeki akhir tahun siapa yang membawa peluangtren body microbiome care mengutamakan keseimbangan kulit tubuhkucing berkepala datar pemburu sungai caramelized peach mousse cake brings elegant fruity flavors to every sliceturkish walnut honey katmerfenomena kafe tanpa menu panjangprompt chatgpt jawaban lebih relevanerin wartia jadi tersangkahasil man city vs fulhamsejarah laptop pertama duniaprediksi milan vs frosinonehasil psm vs persijabek kiri baru manchester unitedwarna honda super cub c125renault twingo uk pricefakta unik burung payungmakna tato gelombang ekgkoleksi ut uniqlo studio ghiblisafinah sahabat nabi muhammadfilm horor werwulf 2026manchester united manager costskalteng fc vs borneo fccara kirim email tahun 1984skandal narkoba militer malaysiafenomena skinny fat tubuh kurusindonesia kembali dewan icaospalletti tanggapi antonio contegejala tumor pankreaskebakaran permukiman baduy lebaksunscreen anessa perlindungan kulitsleep debt tidur akhir pekansifaka madagaskar primata menariperfect liars 2026thai tom yum seafoodpistachio raspberry financierhealthy japanese salmon onigirieid holiday south korea springembroidered bookmarks creativebody language matters firstsingapore preschool teacher jailedfrog fastener jackets fashionalgoritma susunan simbol acakanimasi ornamen klasik tiongkokestetika oriental efek sinematikfilosofi naga visual fantasiilusi kendali perubahan putaranlegenda fenghuang ornamen orientalpengganda probabilitas matematikarisiko deposit qris digitalsimbolisme scorpio karakter mitologivolatilitas distribusi hadiah acakkomunitas mahjong anak mudamahasiswa mahjong budaya visualmahjong digital aksesibilitasmahjong ways animasi mikromahjong ways audio adaptifshio kelinci mahjong ilustrasishio naga mahjong ornamenteknologi mahjong desain oriental futuristikzodiak gemini mahjong dualitaszodiak libra mahjong komposisikomunitas mahjong anak mudamahasiswa mahjong budaya visualmahjong digital aksesibilitasmahjong ways animasi mikromahjong ways audio adaptifshio kelinci mahjong ilustrasishio naga mahjong ornamenteknologi mahjong desain oriental futuristikzodiak gemini mahjong dualitaszodiak libra mahjong komposisianimasi mahjong ways psikologi visualaquarius mahjong kreativitas teknologigenerasi z mahjong desain interaktifmahjong digital audio grafismahjong ways simbol tradisionalmahjong ways teknologi budaya asiashio kelinci budaya mahjongshio naga mahjong ways simboltren mahjong anak muda komunitaszodiak gemini mahjong digitalanak muda permainan digital mahjongfenomena mahjong digital generasi mudafilosofi kesabaran mahjongfilosofi mahjong keseimbanganmahjong ways sistem acakmahjong ways teknologi visualpsikologi animasi mahjongsimbol keberuntungan mahjong budayatren hiburan interaktif mahjongwarisan mahjong desain teknologimahjong ways generasi zmahjong budaya pop leo ilustrasi mahjongshio kelinci mahjonganimasi mikro mahjongaquarius mahjong futuristikshio naga visual mahjongmusik mahjong digitalestetika mahjong gen zshio kuda mahjong modern

I recently listened to a podcast that posed a very interesting concept – something I’ve never considered but listening to the logic behind it gave me pause for thought. The concept is this – if we are to save nature we must, as a society, put a price on it. My first reaction to this was outrage – how dare economists suggest that you must put a price on nature, is nothing sacred? Many environmentalists feel this way and there is a compelling argument for appreciating and protecting nature for nature’s sake not for selfish economic gains.

However, as we know, money is a compelling force for everyone from the farmer trying to eke out a living and keep his family alive by rearing cattle on tracts of the Amazon rainforest cleared for agriculture right up to multinational multimillion dollar corporations who are chasing more profit whatever the moral cost. How do you convince a society with such a short term view, whether they are Individuals focused on making enough money to put dinner on the table for their family or companies showing how profits have increased in order to satisfy shareholders.

‘Rarely will the money to be made by protecting nature match the money to be made by destroying it. Nature offers low rates of return by comparison to other investment’ (1) 

The quote above outlines the thinking of most; quick money is not to be made by protecting nature. This is a fact, however there is a train of thought that is coming to the fore that demands due consideration. This is ‘without nature the economy is nothing’ (2) and this is the concept that may prevail in the constant struggle to stop things such as deforestation in the name of agriculture and pollution through large scale industry.

Economists have been working on attaching a monetary value to nature since the 1960s (3) and in 1997, a team of scientists calculated a dollar value of every ecosystem on the planet and at that time it amounted to 142.7 trillion dollars (4); that’s a hard sum to ignore. Without going into the intricate details of how these figures are calculated (I’m no economist!) I’ll outline an example of what these calculations can be distilled down to; let’s take the example of bees. The majority of our horticultural crops require pollination by bees (and other insects) to be successful. In short without the help of bees, we would not be able to feed humans. So what does this mean in terms of the food grown, harvested and the profit made by farmers and corporations? In direct financial terms: the first attempt at a global value for insect pollination, nearly 20 years ago, came up with a figure of $116bn (£76bn) annually. Surely if there is a monetary value attached to what nature provides us, and such a large one at that, protecting it cannot be ignored.

So how would this work in real terms? You can assign a value to these things but – the farmer still needs to be paid, the corporations still want to show their shareholders profits. How do we turn the monetary value assigned in theory to something that will assist with nature conservation?

One proposal put forward is the concept of ECO-currency (6) which would, in theory, bridge the gap between economics and the environment. An article written by Next Nature Network in 2010 illustrated the idea with the real-life example of Alberto, a Brazilian farmer. Alberto cuts trees in the rainforest, sells the wood and transforms the soil into agricultural farm land. By doing this he makes money to buy food and goods for his family. Obviously, the huge downside of doing this is further destruction of the Brazilian rainforest. Some may say that it’s this farmer’s moral obligation not to destroy the environment. However, particularly for people from industrialized developed countries, it’s hypocritical to expect this farmer to put his livelihood and chance of survival on the line, when the industrial revolution did exactly the same thing to our natural environment at the turn of the century. Searching for ways to economically compensate the farmer to leave the rain forest untouched would be a more helpful and understanding way to tackle this issue.

The ECO Currency project explores the idea of introducing a separate currency for environmental value. For the case of Alberto, this would mean his piece of uncut rainforest would have a certain value in ECOs, and rather than cutting down the trees and to earn money, he could decide to actively steward his piece of rainforest, protect the trees and earn ECOs. The ECOs could be traded for real money, goods and economical benefit for his family. It is proposed that the funding could come from a tiny tax on the financial system, or banks. A tax as low as 0.005 per cent when levied on the funds flowing round the global finance system every day has the power to raise hundreds of billions every year (6).

In answer to the question, can we put a price on nature, I think it’s clear – yes we can. Should we put a price on nature? This is hotly debated and it’s a debate worth having; exhausting all possibilities in the name of trying to work out the best way of protecting our environment is of utmost importance. This may be the idea that’s worth considering.

Kate Goodall

When it comes to trying to put a price on nature, there is one main element that seems problematic to me. It seems, to me, to be the equivalent of attempting to put a price on the existence of value. While environment, as a word, is used for many meanings it essentially describes the context of something. Our environment is the context in which we live and get to have the concept of an economy in the first place. As soon put an economic value on the air we breathe or the sun. There’s no point. Every material item in our economy is in some way directly derived from or obtained using the sun. Fossil fuels hold energy that was obtained from the sun, crops grow from its light, not to mention that the earth would not even have formed without it, much less be warm enough to inhabit. So we don’t try to put a monetary value on it because it would be a pointless exercise. It would remain ubiquitous and people would continue to take it for granted. After all, you can’t remain in a state of awe all of the time.

So why is it okay to try to do this with the planet that we live on? It is obvious that it is impossible to avoid doing so to some extent. When trying to decide where we can build houses, choosing whether or not to extract resources and use them to improve living standards or similar, we have to strike a balance in order to avoid being paralysed by indecision. However, the idea that this ecosystem or that ecosystem is worth £X per year is insufficient. Trying to isolate elements of nature and then pricing them in a sort of bizarre taxonomy neglects the complexity of the planet’s biogeochemistry and how it is inextricably a part of everything that we do.

Joshua Keys

References

1) The Guardian (2012) Putting a price on the rivers and rain diminishes us all. http://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2012/aug/06/price-rivers-rain-greatest-privatisation

2) The Guardian (2012) We must put a price on nature if we are going to save it. http://www.theguardian.com/environment/2012/aug/10/nature-economic-value-campaign

3) Nature (International Weekly Journal of Science) 2009 Biodiversity: Putting a price on nature. http://www.nature.com/news/2009/091118/full/462270a.html

4) Radiolab, Season 13, Episode 3. (2015) Worth. http://www.radiolab.org/story/worth/

5) The Independent (2015) Nature Studies: Is it possible to put a price on nature? And if we can, should we? http://www.independent.co.uk/voices/is-it-possible-to-put-a-price-on-nature-and-if-we-can-should-we-a6736821.html

6) Next Nature Network (2010) ECO Currency – A Proposal to Balance Economical and Environmental Value https://www.nextnature.net/2010/05/eco-currency-%E2%80%93-a-proposal-to-balance-economical-and-environmental-value/

This article was submitted to be published by Groundsure as part of their advertising agreement with Today’s Conveyancer. The views expressed in this article are those of the submitter and not those of Today’s Conveyancer.

Want to have your say? Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Read more stories

Join over 7,000 conveyancing professionals – Check back daily for all the latest news, views, insights and best practice and sign up to our e-newsletter to receive our daily and weekly round ups

You’ll receive the latest updates, analysis, and best practice straight to your inbox.

Features

Generic selectors
Exact matches only
Search in title
Search in content
Post Type Selectors
Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies so that we can provide you with the best user experience possible. Cookie information is stored in your browser and performs functions such as recognising you when you return to our website and helping our team to understand which sections of the website you find most interesting and useful.