Dreamvar Ruling – Mitigating the risk

Dreamvar Ruling – Mitigating the risk

Last week, the Court of Appeal delivered their verdict on Dreamvar v Mishcon de Reya – a case which has put conveyancers on high alert.

Successful in part, the judgment follows ongoing legal proceedings, with the industry eagerly awaiting clarity over a key issue: which party should bear liability where fraud is present in a transaction?

The case centred on firm Mishcon de Reya, who was found liable for breach of trust when its client was tricked into purchasing a London property from a fraudster masquerading as the owner.

Whilst the initial High Court judgment found that Mishcon were liable for breach of trust, the appeal concluded that solicitors acting for the ‘vendor’ also bear responsibility for carrying out sufficient checks. It means that where checks are not carried out, the solicitors acting for the buyer cannot be held solely responsible should money be lost.

Summarising what this means for professionals acting for the seller was Jerome O’Sullivan. The partner at law firm Healys, who acted for Dreamvar throughout the case said:

“The Court of Appeal has confirmed that the vendor’s solicitor is in the best position to carry out reasonable due diligence in investigating to verify the vendor’s identity and ownership of the property for sale.”

“The Court of Appeal has made it clear that, if the vendor’s solicitor does not carry out such checks at all, or carries them out negligently, it will have potential liabilities to the purchaser as breaches of warranty of authority; trust or undertaking.”

It’s worth noting that whilst Mishcon de Reya had not been negligent, the Court upheld that the firm was liable for breach of trust – something which Ben Patten QC, one of the Barrister’s who acted on behalf of Dreamvar said would always be the case for the purchaser’s solicitors.

‘The solicitor for the purchaser will always be liable to his client for breach of trust even though he may not have been negligent. He may be able to obtain relief from sanctions, although he may not do so if his client is of modest means.’

He then went on to highlight how the decision shifts the responsibility for fraud going forward, stating, in relation to cases where the supposed seller is a criminal: ‘The vendor’s solicitor will also be liable. He will have acted in breach of trust and (more importantly) in breach of undertaking. Depending on how he described his client, he may also be liable for breach of warranty of authority. The purchaser’s solicitor will usually be able to obtain a contribution, possibly amounting to an indemnity, from the vendor’s solicitor. The decision thus shifts the risk of such frauds onto the shoulders of the solicitor who acts for the fraudster.’

Whilst cases such as the above have clearly raised awareness of fraud among professionals, the fact that large firms are having to pay out significant sums indicate that no one is safe from being targeted.

Now, more than ever, the need for firms to ensure that sufficient checks are carried out is vital.

It’s not a question of if you’ll get targeted – it’s when.

To discover how Lawyer Checker can help your firm offer the best protection to your clients and their money, please click here.

This article was submitted to be published by Lawyer Checker as part of their advertising agreement with Today’s Conveyancer. The views expressed in this article are those of the submitter and not those of Today’s Conveyancer.

Lawyer Checker


Lawyer Checker announce survey results and Tech Hamper winners






Provider of market-leading risk management solutions to the legal sector.

Lawyer Checker is a leading provider of risk management solutions to the legal sector, offering a full inclusive suite of products and services which have one thing in common – they are all designed to protect and to promote your firm.

Our expert understanding of the legal sector means that we are in a unique position to ensure that your business is protected from the main threats without delay.

We are committed to being proactive when it comes to caring for our clients, and to getting them onto a platform where they are safer.

What does Lawyer Checker do?

Our suite of fraud prevention and cyber security products include:


Thirdfort is the latest in Lawyer Checker's innovative suite of products helping to defend law firms against the persistent threats lurking in the legal sector, by providing enhanced due diligence to source of funds and ID checks. It uses a mobile app to digitally confirm a client's identity by combining facial recognition technology with document scanning and open banking, enabling you to confidently “Know Your Customer." Find out more >

Account and Entity Screen (AES)

AES provides your firm with enhanced risk management when transferring funds by checking the accounts details of a solicitor you are sending funds to against our unique database. This ensures your client funds are sent to a legitimate bank account associated with the vendor’s conveyancing firm. Find out more >

Consumer Bank Account Checker (CBAC)

CBAC offers enhanced due diligence when remitting sales proceeds and balancing payments to consumers. It works by validating the source and destination of funds by checking the bank account details match your client’s personal details when sending or receiving client funds. Find out more >


A vital layer in protecting against email modification fraud, OnDMARC can actively block phishing attacks and obstruct 3rd parties impersonating your email domain to any recipient such as your clients, suppliers or employees. Email fraud is a law firm’s biggest risk. To avoid sensitive data being stolen through email impersonation fraud, safeguard your firm by implementing OnDMARC, otherwise anyone can send an email directly to your customers, suppliers or employees pretending to be you. Find out more >

Cyber Certifications

The National Centre for Cyber Security has identified the legal sector as a top target for cyber criminals. The sensitive data, large sums of money and important information that is held needs protecting to avoid severe damage to clients and your reputation.

Cyber Essentials

Cyber Essentials is a ‘must have’ certification for law firms which will protect your business, prevents data breaches and highlights to your customers, your regulators, the ICO and cyber criminals that you take cyber security seriously and shows you have taken the recommended steps to secure yourselves from potential threats. Getting Cyber Essentials certification for your firm is quick and easy, our in-house expert Cyber Essentials Assessors at Lawyer Checker (Part of Practical Vision Network) can conduct your online assessment and issue your certificate in less than 48hrs. For only £350 plus VAT it will give you peace of mind that you have shielded your law firm from cyber risk.

Cyber Essentials Plus

Our professional in-house assessors can issue official certificates to compliant firms for Cyber Essentials Plus, which is the next step up from Cyber Essentials. It covers the same controls but this time it is independently verified by a site visit from our expert assessor who will carry out a thorough inspection of online devices and web hosts through a detailed network vulnerability scan and certify your security arrangements to Cyber Essentials Plus level.

IASME Governance

Our expert in-house assessors can issue official certificates to compliant firms for IASME which includes Cyber Essentials certification along with a GDPR readiness assessment. It signifies to your customers and shareholders that you consider data protection a priority, and your desire to manage risk by demonstrating a high level of security. This certification is particularly suitable for businesses that are working towards ISO27001 and want a stepping stone, or for those that want to align to ISO27001 but perhaps don’t have the budget to go to a full certification.

ISO 27001

Our expert in-house consultants will help your firm prepare for ISO 27001 certification audits. It is internationally recognised as the most comprehensive and detailed accreditation to help embed a healthy security culture within your business. The consultation focuses on all business areas and not just the IT department. Our execution experts can work with you to implement ISO27001 in a way that works for your business and can provide as much or as little support as you need from project plans, document templates to full implementation. Our professional assessors can even help you to book and prepare for your certification audits.

To safeguard your business, use Lawyer Checker’s comprehensive products and services to arm you and your law firm with the right tools and information to be able to obtain the assurances you need to act in the best interests of your clients.

Key contacts:

Heidi Jenkins
Key Relationship Manager at the Practical Vision Network including Lawyer Checker, Solve Legal Marketing and The Move Exchange.
M: 0330 052 7588 E: [email protected]

Mark Siwiec
Business Development Manager (Cyber) at the Practical Vision Network including Lawyer Checker, Solve Legal Marketing and The Move Exchange.
M: 03300529150 E: [email protected]

Suite 4, Wright House, 67 High Street, Tarporley, Cheshire, CW6 0DP

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.