Prime HeadlineBeritalogyJurna CoreTasty Plate PediaBeauty Glow Pediakilas sepak bolaindokulinerbeautyniquejawara beritawellnesiahubastralythickuliner viralatletic zone hubzoonestifysorotan hari iniSudut LapanganCombatpediaTinta BeritaKuliner HariankuLuxurious BakingLacak Jejak SejarahBerita KecelakaanInformasi Harga SahamUpdate Seputar Berita PenipuanInformasi Seputar Harga EmasBerita Kecelakaan TerkiniBerita PenipuanInformasi Tentang Emasharga emas realtimeHarga Semen IndonesiaInformasi Kenaikan Harga EmasHarga SemenBerita Seputar EsportBerita Seputar KacaFashion IndonesiaBerita Harian SejatiUpdate Berita TerpercayaBerita Utama TerupdateSeklas Kabar BeritaInformasi Berita Bola TerkiniInformasi Berita CepatBerita Terbaru TerpopulerBerita Harian CepatSeputar Berita BolaPacu BeritaUpdate TeknoRanah AutoRumpi TetanggaMega Otomotifdunia faunaJelajah FaunaTatoo Art IndonesiaLoves Diet SehatSkena Fashionprediksi master hari iniUnited GamingFundacion RapalaFakta SehariTren HarapanGadgetkanGosipliciousiNewsComplexiNewsFootballPollux TierFoomer OfficialCommon SightJurnal TempoRuang MistisiNews CombatOhana MagazineLove Food Ready MealsPetite PaulinaBeauty RivalSpecialty Network SllcFilm Terbaru Penuh Pesan MoralMovie AutoAlmansorsMayumioteroCipta WacanaAkademi Keperawatan Yayasan UKIJurnal Keperawatan YUKISekolah Tinggi Ilmu Ekonomi Indonesia Surabayasensa138sensa138sensa138sensa138sensa138sensa138sensa138sensa138sensa138sensa138sensa138sensa138Round Rock JournalBiobaeckereiBornheimerBukemersanacokyakisirTrans To Findslot gacoraloha4daloha4daloha4dkiyo4dtgl.comkiyo4dbmx4dbmx4d loginbmx4d linkBrivifyjuliet4d loginjuliet4djuliet4d linkjuliet4d loginbima88bima88BIMAHOKIbimahokibimahokibima88bociljpsensa69bendera138bendera138bendera138bendera138bendera138bendera138mahjong ways estetika orientaltren mahjong generasi zshio naga mahjong digitalzodiak scorpio desain mahjongmahjong ways animasi mobileshio kuda inspirasi gamezodiak leo mahjong visualpsikologi pola mahjong waysshio kelinci mahjong estetikamasa depan mahjong digital aimahjong ways transformasi digitalmahjong digital anak mudazodiak mahjong budaya digitalshio naga budaya mahjongmahjong ways warisan budayalibra keseimbangan mahjongtren mahjong media sosialshio kuda filosofi mahjongmahjong ways era smartphonescorpio misteri simbol mahjongevolusi mahjong ways generasi mudamahjong digital budaya visual anak mudafilosofi shio naga mahjong digitalzodiak scorpio karakter mahjongbudaya hoki tradisi mahjong waysshio kuda karakter digitalpsikologi warna mahjong waysgenerasi z konten mahjong digitalanimasi transformasi mahjong digital mitos zodiak shio probabilitasemas dunia merosot pasar gelisahharga perak dolar permintaan industriharga emas menjelang desemberpolusi udara influenza Kesehatan anakambisi indonesia geser dominasi thailandpersita klasemen super league bergejolakubed kalahkan toma junior popovshio tikus akhir 2026tren biohacking beauty kulitsiput laut costasiella mirip domba kecil tubuh hijaunya menggemaskanjapanese mentaiko butter rollfenomena kuliner nostalgia jadulresep bakwan jagung telur asintren diet paleo 2026motogp portugal 2026 fp1 resultsunusual apec summit momentsetf emas investor chinaoperasi siber rahasia inggrisburon narkoba singapura ditangkap thailanddesain interior modern nusantarapria muda gagal ginjal cuci darahsharp aquos sense11 meluncurpromo kawasaki imos 2026legenda gunung berkabut nama terlarangmahjong ways budaya teknologi generasi mudashio kelinci filosofi mahjong digitalshio macan transformasi mahjongshio naga mahjong ways budayatampilan mahjong ways hiburan digitalteknologi animasi mahjong waysteknologi visual mahjongtren permainan digital anak muda interaktifzodiak gemini mahjong simbol psikologizodiak leo simbol mahjong kontenzodiak libra mahjong estetika orientalharga emas antam ubs koreksiharga perak prospek investasi globalharga emas zona panas investorputusan icj soal myanmar jadi sorotan rohingya menanti keadilanoppo find x10 smartphone premiumshin tae yong persija hadapi psmmarc marquez gelar MotoGP sejarahzodiak cancer keputusan cintatren architectural collar dresskelelawar hammer headed kepala besarpistachio raspberry mousse domenasi tumpang kediri menyimpan keunikan sambal tempe semangitkonsep Korean vinyl dessert bardiet ocd berat stagnanharga redmi 17 5gkerusakan rumah tasya farasyarisiko kanker kulit di indonesiapenyebab mudah mabuk perjalanankarang gigi radang gusirespons conte manchester unitedtransfer mudryk arsenal chelseaharga byd titan 7 dmvw polo gti clubsport conceptantelop saiga stepa eurasiamakna tato dandelion minimalisnoah converse chuck 70 tartankisah sahabat abu dujanahfilm violent night 2newcastle vs arsenal predictioncop31 memanas komitmen energidua kapal dilarang berlayarnamu balai kota ondel ondeljuara angkat besi malaysia kecelakaanhuawei osta hp flagshipupah minimum jawa tengahmyanmar tolak putusan icj rohingyatren rok satin panjangmakanan tinggi flavonoid sehatmitologi suku aceh alamamari jones tko deaundre pettuskuah pliek u khas acehvegetable cream cheese bagelcheese tteokbokki recipesasian gyeran ppang koreanus chip restrictions tsmcfinding happiness in simpletravis kelce falcons ankle tackleluminous holiday eye makeup trendsaplikasi ojek online tutupanimasi mahjong waysanak muda mahjong video pendekgenerasi z mahjong budaya populeraudio mahjong waysmahjong digital desain ponselmahjong digital audio visual perangkat mahjong ways perubahan desain antarmukamahjong ways estetika orientalmahjong ways transisi layarmahjong ways tipografi antarmukashio anjing mahjong loyalitasmahjong ways warna emas psikologishio babi mahjong ornamenshio ayam mahjong identitas karaktershio kerbau mahjongshio kambing mahjong estetikashio monyet mahjongshio kuda mahjong simbol dinamikashio ular mahjongshio tikus mahjong cerita kreatifzodiak aquarius mahjongtren mahjong komunitas mudazodiak cancer mahjong narasizodiak aries mahjong simbol energizodiak pisces mahjongzodiak capricorn mahjong teknologizodiak scorpio mahjong misteri visualzodiak sagitarius mahjongzodiak virgo mahjong detail visualzodiak taurus mahjong warnarummenigge bela petinggi bayern musialaerin wartia tersangka penganiayaan artufc qatar prochazka stirlinginggris operasi siber empat negaraasean ekonomi myanmar laut china selataneksekusi suntik mati texas kontroversilibernt windows 11 alternativeanime crusaders x codes november 2026virgil van dijk liverpool futurendonesian stock market declineevolusi mahjong ways digitalgen z tradisi mahjongleo karakter fantasi mahjonglibra harmoni mahjong digitalmahjong digital gen zsejarah mahjong hiburan digitalshio kelinci ilustrasi mahjongshio naga mahjong waystren konten mahjong sosialwarna emas hijau mahjongmahjong ways dan rahasia daya tarik simbol emas dalam budaya keberuntungan digitalketika shio naga bertemu mahjong digital: mitos hoki dan pesona visual yang tak pernah pudarzodiak libra dalam dunia mahjong modern: harmoni warna dan ilusi keseimbangan keberuntunganfilosofi shio ular dan mahjong ways: mengapa simbol misterius membuat pengalaman digital lebih memikatmisteri angka delapan pada mahjong digital: dari tradisi hoki hingga psikologi penggunamahjong ways dan zodiak pisces: imajinasi, warna biru, serta cerita keberuntungan di layarshio monyet dalam hiburan mahjong digital: kreativitas, kejutan, dan daya tarik animasi interaktifmengapa efek cahaya mahjong ways terasa membawa hoki? penjelasan desain dan psikologizodiak sagitarius dan mahjong digital: semangat petualangan dalam estetika permainan masa kiniantara hoki dan algoritma mahjong ways: mengapa pola berulang belum tentu menjadi petunjukanimasi mahjong ways mobileaquarius inovasi mahjongestetika oriental mahjongmusik efek suara mahjongpisces fantasi mahjongpsikologi probabilitas mahjongshio kuda visual mahjongshio macan karakter digitalshio ular desain mahjongsimbol mahjong desain kreatifstruktur 5 gulungan 4 baris menarikperhitungan matematika dalam pengelolaan modalangka favorit dan riwayat roulettebonus kasino menggiurkan syarat tersembunyimemahami hubungan return volatilitas risikomenguji strategi dengan data simulasimetode probabilitas perbandingan peluang kasinosatu keputusan meja baccarat pentingstrategi blackjack dan keputusan akhirteori expected value di kasino digitalemas dunia data ekonomi pekan baruharga perak menguji optimisme investorharga emas babak krusial pasarkenaikan ump 2027 berbagai provinsitubuh menggigil tanpa demampersija gagal kalahkan psmtiwi fadia world tour finalsshio anjing dan misteri rezeki akhir tahun siapa yang membawa peluangtren body microbiome care mengutamakan keseimbangan kulit tubuhkucing berkepala datar pemburu sungai caramelized peach mousse cake brings elegant fruity flavors to every sliceturkish walnut honey katmerfenomena kafe tanpa menu panjangprompt chatgpt jawaban lebih relevanerin wartia jadi tersangkahasil man city vs fulhamsejarah laptop pertama duniaprediksi milan vs frosinonehasil psm vs persijabek kiri baru manchester unitedwarna honda super cub c125renault twingo uk pricefakta unik burung payungmakna tato gelombang ekgkoleksi ut uniqlo studio ghiblisafinah sahabat nabi muhammadfilm horor werwulf 2026manchester united manager costskalteng fc vs borneo fccara kirim email tahun 1984skandal narkoba militer malaysiafenomena skinny fat tubuh kurusindonesia kembali dewan icaospalletti tanggapi antonio contegejala tumor pankreaskebakaran permukiman baduy lebaksunscreen anessa perlindungan kulitsleep debt tidur akhir pekansifaka madagaskar primata menariperfect liars 2026thai tom yum seafoodpistachio raspberry financierhealthy japanese salmon onigirieid holiday south korea springembroidered bookmarks creativebody language matters firstsingapore preschool teacher jailedfrog fastener jackets fashionalgoritma susunan simbol acakanimasi ornamen klasik tiongkokestetika oriental efek sinematikfilosofi naga visual fantasiilusi kendali perubahan putaranlegenda fenghuang ornamen orientalpengganda probabilitas matematikarisiko deposit qris digitalsimbolisme scorpio karakter mitologivolatilitas distribusi hadiah acakkomunitas mahjong anak mudamahasiswa mahjong budaya visualmahjong digital aksesibilitasmahjong ways animasi mikromahjong ways audio adaptifshio kelinci mahjong ilustrasishio naga mahjong ornamenteknologi mahjong desain oriental futuristikzodiak gemini mahjong dualitaszodiak libra mahjong komposisikomunitas mahjong anak mudamahasiswa mahjong budaya visualmahjong digital aksesibilitasmahjong ways animasi mikromahjong ways audio adaptifshio kelinci mahjong ilustrasishio naga mahjong ornamenteknologi mahjong desain oriental futuristikzodiak gemini mahjong dualitaszodiak libra mahjong komposisianimasi mahjong ways psikologi visualaquarius mahjong kreativitas teknologigenerasi z mahjong desain interaktifmahjong digital audio grafismahjong ways simbol tradisionalmahjong ways teknologi budaya asiashio kelinci budaya mahjongshio naga mahjong ways simboltren mahjong anak muda komunitaszodiak gemini mahjong digitalanak muda permainan digital mahjongfenomena mahjong digital generasi mudafilosofi kesabaran mahjongfilosofi mahjong keseimbanganmahjong ways sistem acakmahjong ways teknologi visualpsikologi animasi mahjongsimbol keberuntungan mahjong budayatren hiburan interaktif mahjongwarisan mahjong desain teknologimahjong ways generasi zmahjong budaya pop leo ilustrasi mahjongshio kelinci mahjonganimasi mikro mahjongaquarius mahjong futuristikshio naga visual mahjongmusik mahjong digitalestetika mahjong gen zshio kuda mahjong modern
Introduction
Without doubt confidentiality is at the corner stone of a solicitors practice. In  Miers v Evans, (1839 3 Jur 170) Patteson J held :
‘…it would be a dangerous doctrine to lay down, that we can compel an attorney, because he is an attorney, to give a copy of, or produce, a document in his hands belonging to a client, except at the instance of the client himself … when an attorney holds a document for a client, it is not competent to the court, in an action by a third party against the attorney, to order him to give a copy of it…’
The current SRA Code of Conduct (October 2013) Chapter 4 notes “Protection of confidential information is a fundamental feature of your relationship with clients. It exists as a concept both as a matter of law and as a matter of conduct. This duty continues despite the end of the retainer and even after the death of the client.”
The duty can lead to a number of difficult issues for solicitors and indeed clients. Take a typical scenario where a lender is reviewing its security and considering a potential claim to recover its loss following default by a borrower. As part of that process it will be necessary to review the documents from the original lending transaction. That will involve obtaining the file from the Solicitors who acted when the lender took security. 
If the solicitors acted for the borrower it would require the borrower to consent given the key duty of confidentiality. If the borrower is involved in any wrongdoing such consent is very unlikely. 
What if the solicitors acted for both parties? In such a case there are two separate retainers. Accordingly the borrowers consent is required.  In Nationwide Building Society v Various Solicitors, [1999] PNLR 52, Blackburne J held 
‘…there was no implied waiver of confidentiality nor legal professional privilege by the borrower in favour of the lender, nor any implied authorisation for the solicitor to make disclosure to the lender of documents passing between the borrower and the solicitor. Any implied authorisation was merely an authorisation to pass on the information and not to divulge the communication itself’.
The previous Code of Conduct (2007) provided a more detailed guide on joint retainers. Paragraph 8 (c) provided:

“Where a lender asks for a conveyancing file and you have kept a joint file for both borrower and lender clients, you cannot, without the consent of the borrower, send the whole file to the lender, unless the lender can show to your satisfaction that there is a prima facie case of fraud. If the client does not consent, you should send only those parts of the file which relate to work done for the lender’.

It should of course be noted that the privilege is that of the client not the solicitors. 
Say Something
The right to assert privilege by the client was noted by Blackburne J in the Nationwide case above to be absolute in nature. It was said  “The lawyer’s mouth is "shut forever". 
In the context of lender claims the absolute right of privilege has been the subject of further consideration by the court and a novel approach by lenders. In Mortgage Express v Sawali [2010] EWHC 3054 (Ch) (22 November 2010) the lenders sought delivery up of a number of files from a predecessor firm of the defendant solicitors. There was a joint retainer between the borrower and the lender. The defendants argued that the lender was not entitled to the entire file where some documents were the borrowers and thus covered by privilege. 
The Court noted the borrowers right to privilege and confidentiality as set out in Nationwide Building Society v Various Solicitors, [1999] PNLR 52, and the then SRA 2007 Code Of Conduct . However in this case materially the borrowers had signed a declaration in favour of the lender which stated “I/We irrevocably authorise my/our conveyancer to send their entire file relating to the whole transaction (not just the loan) to you at your request”
The lender argued that having signed the declaration, the borrowers did not retain any right of privilege. Whilst there were arguments mounted by the solicitors as to the meaning and effect of the declaration (raised on behalf of the borrowers) the court held that the declaration was unambiguous and binding upon the lender and borrower. In the context of a loan transaction there had to be frank disclosure. 
HHJ Simon Brown QC held that the lender was entitled to the files. As a matter of ‘commercial commonsense’ against the background knowledge that the declaration was essential to make the transaction work, the declaration must be objectively construed to mean exactly what it says.
The Borrower expressly authorised his conveyancer to provide ‘the entire file’ to the lender for the purposes of entering into the transaction notwithstanding the absolute privilege at common law. 
In simple terms this was a contractual matter between the parties.  The declaration was to be construed as a clear waiver of privilege, not unduly onerous or unfair.
Mortgage Business Plc v Oliver and Co [2013] EWHC 3240 (QB) (unreported) provides a further interesting encroach upon the privilege rule. This was a decision of District Judge Lambert sitting at Bristol District Registry. 
The lender sought delivery up against solicitors in respect of documents contained in various conveyancing files which belonged to the borrowers. The solicitors had acted for the lender and the borrowers. It was alleged by the lenders that the borrowers had made certain representations as to funds available. 
Pursuant to the mortgage conditions, the borrowers appointed the lender as attorney pending full repayment of the loan. The powers of attorney entitled the lender  to  instruct any person, such as a solicitor, who held documents relating to the properties, to allow "any documents about the property" to be viewed or copied by, or sent to, them.
The lender argued that the powers of attorney amounted to express consent by the borrowers to the inspection or delivery up of confidential or privileged information. The solicitors argued that they were obliged to assert the borrowers’ rights of confidentiality and privilege, and that the powers of attorney did not amount to a waiver of those rights. 
The Court held that the power of attorney had to be construed strictly. It noted Mortgage Express v Sawali [2010] EWHC 3054 (Ch) (22 November 2010)   and held that the power of attorney amounted to an effective waiver of privilege and confidentiality in relation to the documents. The clause was unambiguous clearly binding, and its construction was clear. 
The court held that the power of attorney should not be restricted so as to apply only to documents relating to the property. The phrase "any documents about the property" was wide enough to include documents relating to payment of a mortgage. Whilst the power of attorney related only to the provision of copies of documents, and the lender sought delivery up, under the terms of the power of attorney the lender was entitled to either inspect the documents or obtain delivery. 
Accordingly the lender was entitled to delivery of the files. 
Conclusion
Both Mortgage Express v Sawali [2010] EWHC 3054 and Mortgage Business Plc v Oliver and Co [2013] EWHC 3240 highlight contractual provisions which are very often overlooked by lenders and borrowers and their advisors. It proves a further weapon for the lender to deploy prior to any potential claim and strikes at the heart of privilege. Most well drawn charges will contain a clause appointing the lender as having a power of attorney with the consequence that the borrower will be deemed to have waived privilege and confidentiality. Whilst in certain situations a lender can apply for pre action disclosure, such application cannot get around the privilege rule. Accordingly adopting the contractual approach can be a fatal blow to borrowers and third parties.
Given its contractual nature one issue may arise. If the borrower is a consumer for the purposes of the Unfair Terms in Consumer Contracts Regulations 1999, there may be an issue as to whether a clause in the charge is unfair and therefore potentially unenforceable. 
Finally it is worth recalling that the courts retain supervision and jurisdiction over solicitors. Notably section 68 of the Solicitors Act 1974 provides that the courts have jurisdiction to make orders for the delivery up by a solicitor of any documents in their possession. Again that power is subject to the rule of privilege and the contractual waiver noted in the cases above. 
Counsel for Sawali sought to raise a number of submissions that the court’s inherent jurisdiction over its officers did not extend to cases where the applicant had no underlying substantive cause of action against the solicitor for delivery up of the file; and/or the solicitor’s client was not a party to the application Those submissions were rejected by the court on the basis of the contractual provision between the lender and the borrower.
Perhaps the lawyer’s mouth is open gasping for air at the erosion of a sacred rule?
I would like to thank and acknowledge Westlaw UK for highlighting and reporting Mortgage Business Plc v Oliver and Co [2013] EWHC 3240.
Kind regards

Want to have your say? Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Read more stories

Join over 7,000 conveyancing professionals – Check back daily for all the latest news, views, insights and best practice and sign up to our e-newsletter to receive our daily and weekly round ups

You’ll receive the latest updates, analysis, and best practice straight to your inbox.

Features

Generic selectors
Exact matches only
Search in title
Search in content
Post Type Selectors
Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies so that we can provide you with the best user experience possible. Cookie information is stored in your browser and performs functions such as recognising you when you return to our website and helping our team to understand which sections of the website you find most interesting and useful.