Prime HeadlineBeritalogyJurna CoreTasty Plate PediaBeauty Glow Pediakilas sepak bolaindokulinerbeautyniquejawara beritawellnesiahubastralythickuliner viralatletic zone hubzoonestifysorotan hari iniSudut LapanganCombatpediaTinta BeritaKuliner HariankuLuxurious BakingLacak Jejak SejarahBerita KecelakaanInformasi Harga SahamUpdate Seputar Berita PenipuanInformasi Seputar Harga EmasBerita Kecelakaan TerkiniBerita PenipuanInformasi Tentang Emasharga emas realtimeHarga Semen IndonesiaInformasi Kenaikan Harga EmasHarga SemenBerita Seputar EsportBerita Seputar KacaFashion IndonesiaBerita Harian SejatiUpdate Berita TerpercayaBerita Utama TerupdateSeklas Kabar BeritaInformasi Berita Bola TerkiniInformasi Berita CepatBerita Terbaru TerpopulerBerita Harian CepatSeputar Berita BolaPacu BeritaUpdate TeknoRanah AutoRumpi TetanggaMega Otomotifdunia faunaJelajah FaunaTatoo Art IndonesiaLoves Diet SehatSkena Fashionprediksi master hari iniUnited GamingFundacion RapalaFakta SehariTren HarapanGadgetkanGosipliciousiNewsComplexiNewsFootballPollux TierFoomer OfficialCommon SightJurnal TempoRuang MistisiNews CombatOhana MagazineLove Food Ready MealsPetite PaulinaBeauty RivalSpecialty Network SllcFilm Terbaru Penuh Pesan MoralMovie AutoAlmansorsMayumioteroCipta WacanaAkademi Keperawatan Yayasan UKIJurnal Keperawatan YUKISekolah Tinggi Ilmu Ekonomi Indonesia Surabayasensa138sensa138sensa138sensa138sensa138sensa138sensa138sensa138sensa138sensa138sensa138sensa138Round Rock JournalBiobaeckereiBornheimerBukemersanacokyakisirTrans To Findslot gacoraloha4daloha4daloha4dkiyo4dtgl.comkiyo4dbmx4dbmx4d loginbmx4d linkBrivifyjuliet4d loginjuliet4djuliet4d linkjuliet4d loginbima88bima88BIMAHOKIbimahokibimahokibima88bociljpsensa69sensa69bendera138bendera138bendera138bendera138bendera138bendera138misteri pohon raksasa gerbang gaibsamsung intelligent eyewear preorder hargabyd ti7 vs jaecoo j8 shsrisiko celana dalam ketat priajepang taklukkan brasil di singapurajennifer coppen umumkan kehamilan justin hubnernemkov vs bilostenniy pfl dubaikapal pesiar american heritage ditabrak tankerbts-singapore-national-gallery-art-experience celebrating christmas and new yearfenomena permainan klasik di era digitalgame klasik dengan teknologi moderngaya hidup permainan keterampilan sosialgenerasi muda gandrungi permainan digitalhiburan digital modern untuk semua usiakeseruan menyusun ubin di mejamengenal daya tarik permainan ubin kembali viralpermainan mahjong tradisional lintas generasistrategi kombinasi tiles berdaya tariktren permainan mahjong empat orangkecermatan menyusun ubin menjadi kuncikesalahan membuang ubin yang sering menghambatmemanfaatkan informasi ubin keluar perkirakan susunan kartu membaca ubin buangan lawan empat pemainmenggabungkan observasi perhitungan dan keputusanpemilihan kombinasi ubin yang tepatperhitungan peluang membantu memilih ubinstrategi bertahan menyerang peluang menangstrategi mengelola risiko kombinasi besarteknik mengatur kombinasi kartu efisienemas dunia berusaha pulih tekanan suku bunga masih membayangiharga perak menantang ekspektasi pasarharga emas peluang akhir tahunmobil hybrid merek jepang memimpin pasarprabowo ktt asean 49 diplomasi indonesiamalaysia takluk china kartu merahmarc marquez rekor motogp portugal 2026zodiak sagitarius kejutan besar takdir berbedatren barrel leg jeans siluet denimkatak berambut afrika cakar tulangbrown sugar boba brioche recipekorean crispy rice paper dumpling renyahkafe konsep listening bar music bersantapvivo v80 series indonesiafeni rose minta maafftse russell status pasar indonesiacara ngobrol dengan orang baruuji terbang starship spacexfolarin balogun ke mudumfries di real madridharga kia carens evpeugeot e208 electric hatchback reviewfakta unik ular anakondadesain tato anjing minimaliskoleksi vans x pringlekisah salman al farisisinopsis the judge returnsgermany beat serbia nations leaguecisco integrasikan claude mythoswarga temukan di tumpukan sampahkebiasaan menggigit kuku diam diamprabowo beri penghargaan relawanciryl gane kalahkan josh hokitmesin truk menyala saat berhentikampung ambon digerebek lagichatgpt bikin foto dan sketsalaura mercier translucent loose powdersit to stand exercise makin diliriksejarah kelam afrika membagi wilayahnyaaustralian restaurant pineapple pizzatexas smoked brisket mealsuniversities struggle ai writinganthony olascuaga kalahkan yuberjen martinezkorean rose tteokbokki creamyblueberry crumble cheesecake barshealthy ambition personal boundariestiger woods golf comeback recoverywinter coat trends 2027estetika kaligrafi dan ornamen tradisionalfenomena qris ubah kebiasaan transaksiriset memori visual dan animasicara kerja algoritma pengacak angkaperan simbol tradisional moderntransformasi pembayaran mengubah kebiasaan konsumenpsikologi ketidakpastian otak manusianavigasi animasi dan kenyamanan penggunawarna dan suara memengaruhi persepsirahasia desain interaktif modern aksesibilitasperbandingan lenovo yoga tabkabar kehamilan jennifer coppensirene peringatan di bahrainperjanjian dagang indonesia kanadadana cadangan pesangon danantaraprediksi jerman vs belandainden toyota land cruiser fjgunther werks vs eccentricakuda akhal teke turkmenistanmakna tato fase bulanair jordan 4 spotlightkisah samurah bin jundabsinopsis drakor the scarecrowportugal without cristiano ronaldoadaptasi antarmuka beragam layarbias konfirmasi rangkaian acakdurasi layar konsentrasi keputusanindependensi kejadian mekanisme rngliterasi smartphone transaksi qrismakna budaya simbol klasikpergeseran permainan meja virtual persepsi pola susunan acakrendering transisi simbol halusvolatilitas frekuensi hasil acakfilosofi simbol permainan tiongkokidentitas visual preferensi generasiinovasi antarmuka kesadaran finansialintegrasi pembayaran risiko finansialinterpretasi estetika budaya asialiterasi keamanan transaksi qrisornamen tradisional desain digitalperlindungan data layanan qrisqris transaksi dan keamanansejarah mahjong budaya populerpenelitian struktur algoritma modernprobabilitas simbol digitalriset numerik rtp terkiniriset perilaku timing bermainsimulasi pola aktivitas variatifevaluasi rtp fleksibel harianfenomena putaran harian digitalkajian pola strategis dinamismodel komputasi putaran virtualobservasi timing strategi akuratanimasi visual nilai hasilaudit independen mekanisme peluangbahasa antarmuka aturan permainanbatas pengeluaran siaran langsungilusi pola hasil acakinformasi peluang risiko berbayarkecerahan layar kenyamanan visualmitologi zeus animasi modernsejarah simbol naga asiatransparansi layanan hiburan digitalmodel putaran awalobservasi probabilitas modernpola algoritma visualpola interaksi kuantitatifrtp distribusi matematisrtp variabel performatiming ritme sistemtiming unsur elektronikevaluasi putaran lanjutankajian momentum numerikkajian rtp perhitunganobservasi variasi numerikpemantauan rtp aktualpenelitian simulasi komputasiriset algoritma statistikstudi variabel komputasianalisis kecenderungan visualcatatan analitik digitalevaluasi ekosistem putarankajian ritme harianobservasi ritme sistem numerikpemodelan rtp sebaran elektronikprobabilitas putaran statistik terukurriset timing simbol virtualsimulasi variabel numerikstudi timing informasi digitalvariasi teknologi matematisanalisa transformasi karakter digitalevaluasi algoritmik variabel kompleksevaluasi rtp distribusi terstrukturevaluasi pola frekuensi modernkajian timing ritme digitalobservasi putaran dinamis algoritmikpemodelan rtp variabel digitalpenelitian timing statistik harianperforma algoritmik matematisriset rtp informasi terstruktursimulasi numerik variabel terukurstudi pola distribusi simbolanalisis putaran numerik moderndistribusi fitur probabilistik terukurevaluasi nominal data historisevolusi mekanisme visual kontemporerfrekuensi ritme aktivitas digitalindikator statistik sistem digital observasi respons mesin terukurpemetaan sampel acak digitalpengujian numerik algoritma modernpengukuran temporal aktivitas interaktifvariasi tempo platform modernevolusi mahjong sebagai hiburan sosial berbasis aplikasifenomena apophenia mahjong 2 melihat pola keacakanfenomena qris preferensi pembayaran konsumenjejak ornamen mahjong memiliki evolusi desain modernmahjong ways dan seni hiburan modernmisteri rng mahjong ways sulit diprediksipsikologi audio adaptif suara dan persepsi penggunapsikologi pengeluaran pentingnya anggaran hiburanpsikologi warna cerah mempengaruhi respon otaktransformasi pembayaran nontunai layanan hiburanadaptasi ritme perilakuevolusi antarmuka digitalevolusi fitur interaktifobservasi momentum interaksipergeseran kebiasaan digitalperpaduan mekanisme visualsebaran hasil simulasitransisi tempo aktivitastransparansi dinamika nilaivariasi respons historis

Planning essentials case update: when can an enforcement notice against an unlawful use also require the removal of related structures?

There are currently two different limitation periods for breaches of planning law dependent on the type of breach. The general rule is that where there has been a breach of planning control consisting of building operations without planning permission, no enforcement action can be taken 4 years after the operations were substantially completed.

Whereas, where there has been an unlawful change of use (other than to a single dwelling house in respect of which the 4-year rule also applies) or other breach of planning control the period is 10 years.

However, what happens when the breach involves both an unlawful use (which has not yet reached the 10-year threshold) together with unlawful building operations (which have passed the 4-year threshold)?

In 1980, the High Court in Murfitt v Secretary of State for the Environment considered the case of a farmyard where there was an unlawful parking use together with unlawful works (including the construction of an office and hard-standing). The local planning authority served an enforcement notice requiring the site to be restored to its former state (i.e., requiring not only that the unlawful use cease but that the related physical structures also be removed). The landowner argued that the structures had been on site for more than four years and thus physical restoration of the site was beyond the powers of the authority. However, the High Court held that the enforcement notice was valid – the structures were secondary to the use and were not saved by the 4-year rule.

In subsequent cases, the Courts have clarified that it is necessary to focus on the true nature of the breach, which then confirms which limitation period is to apply. If the works were undertaken for (and could be used for) another lawful use, then they will fall outside Murfitt.

The High Court recently considered these principles in the case of Caldwell v Secretary of State for Levelling Up, Housing & Communities which concerned an alleged unlawful change of use from agricultural to residential associated with the construction of a dwelling and incidental structures. The Court confirmed that it would be a step too far to extend Murfitt to allow enforcement against operational development which is itself the source of or fundamental to the change of use. That would clearly be contrary to the statutory 4-year limitation period.

The new Levelling Up and Regeneration Act envisages (subject to Regulations being enacted) a single limitation period of 10 years for all breaches of planning control. It remains to be seen whether transitional provisions will apply. In the meantime, Caldwell serves as a useful reminder on the limitations of a local authority’s power to require removal of operational development in conjunction with an unlawful change of use and the need to scrutinise enforcement notices carefully.

Written by Sadie Pitman, Charles Russell Speechlys

Want to have your say? Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Read more stories

Join over 7,000 conveyancing professionals – Check back daily for all the latest news, views, insights and best practice and sign up to our e-newsletter to receive our daily and weekly round ups

You’ll receive the latest updates, analysis, and best practice straight to your inbox.

Features

Generic selectors
Exact matches only
Search in title
Search in content
Post Type Selectors
Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies so that we can provide you with the best user experience possible. Cookie information is stored in your browser and performs functions such as recognising you when you return to our website and helping our team to understand which sections of the website you find most interesting and useful.