Technology promises to transform conveyancing, but are firms solving the right problems? After a late-night experiment with an online comparison service triggered a relentless barrage of automated emails and sales messages, this article from regular columnist Peter Ambrose explores the difference between using technology and using it well.
I’ve always believed that while technology is a tricky mistress, businesses must embrace it appropriately to be successful. You only need to look at Amazon or Meta to see this is the case. The argument goes that conveyancing firms that embrace technology will become dominant, and if you don’t deploy the latest software you are doomed to fail, or worse, someone will go on LinkedIn and call you a dinosaur – despite this being a clear breach of your human rights under the UNHCR.
The important word here is “appropriate.” It is not the use of technology that’s critical, but HOW it is used where the problem lies. If you’re producing completion statements using Word, managing pre-contact enquiries with Outlook or heaven forbid getting Alexa to give your clients a case update, then sure, you’re using technology, but maybe not in the most effective way.
I recently experienced first-hand the impact of where implementing technology resulted in irritation rather than delight. One Friday night, after a few bottles of Peroni, I decided to go online and try out a new comparison service that promised conveyancing based on quality not price and get a quote to buy a £500K flat in Guildford.
What happened next was telling.
Unleashing a tide even King Canute couldn’t stop
After answering numerous questions asking whether I was getting a mortgage, buying with another person, using an ISA and my role in the infamous Nigel Lawson student demonstrations in Blaby, Leicestershire in 1984, I clicked Submit. I waited with bated breath to receive quotes from “reputable and expert local firms who would make the process of buying my flat a joyful and heart-warming experience”. At least that’s what the marketing material said, although confusingly, when the quotes arrived seconds later, three firms were in Yorkshire, one in Manchester and one was in Dubai.
I was bombarded with all manner of promises, numbers and bright colourful cover pages showing happy families unpacking boxes in their beautiful new home. I sent my marketing director an irritated email explaining that the lack of happy family images on our own quotes was clearly why we weren’t winning more business. He jumped on ChatGPT and instantly produced a beautifully happy image.
Whilst the initial email onslaught caught me off guard, what really surprised me was the sheer aggressive tenacity of these automated systems. So much so, I made a note of the timings. I submitted the enquiry at 8:32pm and received emails from five firms immediately, but one of them, decided I might have missed it and sent two more – at 10:33pm and 01:33am. In each of these, I was warned about the time sensitive nature of making a decision and their generous discount would run out very soon.
Having followed mystery shopping best-practice and changed one of the digits in my mobile number, I can only apologise to the individual who had received the numerous phone calls from these “local expert lawyers”. I know this because for the next two weeks I received one or two emails a day telling me how they had left a message on my voicemail and time was passing.
The pressure was on and this was before I had even found a property to buy.
Just because it’s clever doesn’t make it right
Reflecting on this experience, where multiple emails were used to gain a result in my making a decision to use a law firm, made it clear that while technology can be a force for good, it has to be used in a manner that is actually useful for our clients and indeed ourselves. For example, one of the most common misunderstandings I see from technologists trying to sell me products is that conveyancing is a process that can be replaced by robotic automation, making human involvement unnecessary.
The reality is this is simply not the case. Where the sulking brood of LinkedIn ranters protesting about the ‘Amazonisation’ of conveyancing are correct, albeit in their thinking rather than their sour negativity, is it cannot be compared to buying services such as insurance online. These are quick transactions taking a few hours where problems can be ironed out quickly, although there are rare occasions (such as forgetting to declare a speeding ticket in Bracknell) where it is necessary to pick up the phone and talk with someone.
The benefits from technology will be realised by those who use it to solve the real problems we’re seeing today; the use of AI by clients to question and undermine our expertise and the need to improve the quality and compliance of the content we produce. If you’re a lawyer, don’t be pressurised into implementing technology that does not address real issues, even if, like your online conveyancing quote, you’ve been told that the offer is time limited and you should buy now to avoid losing out.
About the author
Peter Ambrose is the owner of The Partnership and Legalito – specialising in the delivery of transparent and ultra-efficient conveyancing services and software.
The views expressed in this feature are those of the author and not those of Today’s Conveyancer.















